Contesting a Will for Lack of Capacity in BC: What Families in Surrey Should Know
When a person makes a will, they must have the mental capacity required to understand what they are doing. If you believe a loved one did not understand the nature and effect of their will, the property they were dealing with, or the people who might reasonably expect to benefit, you may be considering a challenge. In British Columbia, lack of testamentary capacity is a distinct ground for disputing a will. It is not enough that the distribution seems unfair or that the person made a decision the family disagrees with.
For families in Surrey, Guildford and across the Lower Mainland, the first practical step is to preserve the will, estate records and relevant medical and communication records, then obtain legal guidance promptly. A capacity challenge can affect probate and estate administration, so timing and evidence matter.
What does testamentary capacity mean?
Testamentary capacity asks whether the will-maker had sufficient mental ability when the will was made. The inquiry focuses on whether the person understood they were making a will and its general effect, had a general understanding of the property being distributed, and could appreciate the people who might have claims on their estate. The person must also be able to make a decision free of a disorder of the mind that distorts their judgment about the dispositions in the will.
This is a functional, time-specific question. A diagnosis such as dementia does not automatically prove that a will is invalid. A person may have periods of clearer thinking, and the nature or severity of an illness may change over time. Conversely, the absence of a formal diagnosis does not establish capacity. The evidence must be considered in relation to the date the will was signed and the decisions made in it.
Capacity is different from undue influence and wills variation
Families often use “contesting a will” to describe several different legal issues. They should be kept separate because the questions and evidence differ.
Lack of capacity concerns whether the will-maker had the necessary mental ability when making the will. Undue influence concerns whether another person exerted pressure that overpowered the will-maker’s free choice. A will can be challenged on both grounds where the evidence supports them, but suspicion or opportunity alone does not prove either one.
A wills variation claim under section 60 of the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA) generally accepts that the will is valid and asks the court to change its distribution for a spouse or child. It is not a claim that the will-maker lacked capacity. Read our overview of wills variation claims under WESA in Surrey BC and the related guide to undue influence in BC estate disputes.
Evidence that may matter in a BC capacity dispute
No single document necessarily decides a case. A court assesses the evidence as a whole, including what the will-maker said and did around the time the will was prepared and signed. Potentially relevant material may include:
- The will-making file: drafts, notes, instructions, attendance notes and correspondence from the lawyer or notary who prepared the will.
- Medical records: records close to the signing date may help explain the person’s cognition, medications, diagnosis and day-to-day functioning. Access to these records may require proper authority or a court process.
- Witness observations: people who interacted with the will-maker around that time may describe memory, understanding, confusion or changes in behaviour. Specific observations are more useful than broad conclusions.
- The will’s development: earlier wills, changes in beneficiaries, and the reasons given for changes may provide context. A surprising change is not proof of incapacity by itself.
- Property and family context: information about assets, family relationships, dependency and the will-maker’s stated intentions may help assess what they understood.
- Execution evidence: the signing circumstances, who was present, and whether the will-maker appeared to understand the document can be relevant.
Keep original documents and messages intact. Make a dated chronology of events and identify potential witnesses while memories are fresh. Avoid coaching witnesses or asking anyone to alter records. A lawyer can help determine what material can be obtained and how it may properly be used.
Who can challenge a will, and when?
A person with a legal interest in the estate may have standing to challenge a will, but the right to bring a particular claim depends on the facts and the relief sought. A beneficiary under an earlier will, a person who would inherit if the disputed will were set aside, or another person affected by the estate may have an interest. Do not assume that being a relative alone is enough, or that the rules for a capacity challenge are identical to the rules for a WESA section 60 variation claim.
Timing is important. Probate can move forward while family members are still trying to understand what happened. If a grant has issued, the estate may be administered or assets distributed. Get prompt legal guidance about the procedural steps available, whether a response to a probate application is needed, and whether any protective court order should be considered. Different claims and remedies can have different limitation periods; do not rely on the 180-day period for a wills variation claim as if it automatically governs every will challenge.
How the process may work
- Clarify the concern. Identify the specific will, signing date, suspected cognitive issue and the result you believe the evidence may support.
- Secure the documents. Obtain the will and available estate information, and preserve relevant correspondence, records and earlier estate-planning documents.
- Review the evidence. A lawyer can assess the will file, timeline, potential witnesses and available medical evidence, and explain the strengths and uncertainties.
- Consider the probate posture. Determine whether probate has been applied for or granted and what steps may be required to protect your position.
- Explore resolution. Where appropriate, parties may exchange information and consider negotiation or mediation. Settlement depends on the evidence and the parties’ positions.
- Proceed in court if necessary. If the dispute cannot be resolved, the court may need to decide whether the will is valid and what orders should follow.
Each estate dispute is different. A clear chronology and well-preserved evidence can help the parties assess the issue, but neither guarantees a particular result.
Common mistakes to avoid
Do not treat an unequal or unexpected gift as proof of incapacity. Do not assume a dementia diagnosis settles the question, or that a person who could hold a conversation necessarily understood a complex will. Avoid waiting until the estate is distributed before asking what procedural options remain. Also avoid confronting witnesses in a way that may affect their recollection. Preserve evidence, record what you personally observed, and get guidance before taking steps that could affect the estate.
What it may cost
Contested estate work is billed at from $400 per hour plus tax. The total depends on the records to review, the number of parties, the complexity of the evidence and whether the dispute settles or proceeds through court. Where the claim is clear, we will discuss a range before the work begins and speak plainly about whether the likely cost is proportionate to the estate and the outcome being pursued. No result or total cost can be guaranteed in advance.
Frequently asked questions
Does dementia automatically invalidate a will in BC?
No. A diagnosis alone does not decide testamentary capacity. The issue is the will-maker’s ability at the time the will was made, assessed with the relevant evidence.
Can a person have capacity on one day and not another?
Capacity is assessed in context and at the relevant time. A person’s condition may fluctuate, so evidence close to the signing date can be important.
Is an unfair will the same as an invalid will?
No. A capacity challenge asks whether the will-maker had the required mental ability. A wills variation claim asks whether a valid will should be changed for a spouse or child under WESA section 60.
Can I challenge a will after probate has been granted?
A grant does not by itself answer whether a challenge can proceed, but administration may be underway. Get prompt guidance about the grant, the estate’s status and the steps available in your circumstances.
What should I bring to an initial meeting?
Bring the will or any copy you have, earlier wills if available, the probate documents, a timeline of events, relevant messages and the names of people with direct observations. Do not delay seeking guidance while waiting to collect every record.
If you are concerned that a loved one’s BC will was made without the required capacity, a short conversation can help identify the relevant dates, records and next steps. Law Boutique serves clients in Surrey, Guildford and the Lower Mainland.
Book a consultation to discuss the estate and the available options.
